Victims
According to police reports, two people were killed and an additional 28 sustained injuries. One victim died at the scene and another at a local hospital; they were later identified as Aaliyah Gonzales and Kylis Fagbemi.
[20]
Nine victims were transported to the hospital by ambulance, while twenty victims transported themselves to area hospitals. The ages of the victims ranged from 13 to 32, with fifteen of the victims being under 18 years old.
[21][22] The
University of Maryland Medical Center took in twelve victims at its
Shock Trauma Center and four were treated at its pediatric emergency department, while
MedStar Harbor Hospital treated nineteen patients.
[23][24]
In November 2023, the families of shooting victims, including those of Fagbemi and Gonzalez, said they were planning to sue the city and state over the incident, seeking a combined $150 million in damages.
[25] The families will be represented in the lawsuit by civil rights attorney
Billy Murphy Jr.[26]
Aftermath
Vigils were held in the Brooklyn community following the shooting.
[27][18] The Mayor's Office of Neighborhood Safety and Engagement (MONSE) deployed its Peace Mobile to distribute household items and resources to Brooklyn residents at the Brooklyn Homes community center and through social workers and local charities.
[18][28] The Baltimore Police Department had "enhanced deployment" in some areas of Baltimore during
July 4 celebrations in the city, including at the Cherry Hill Festival.
[29]
Investigation
Acting Baltimore Police Commissioner Richard Worley has confirmed that there were "at least three"[6] people who fired at the scene and that more than three firearms were used in the shooting,[30] with casings from more than a dozen guns being found by investigators at the crime scene,[16] including six fired from a rifle-caliber pistol,[31] although it is currently unclear if every gun is tied to the mass shooting.[6] The Baltimore Police Department offered a $28,000 reward for information on the suspects.[32]
During its investigation, the Baltimore Police Department had seized the personal belongings of several of the shooting victims while they underwent surgery, despite promises from the department to "minimize or eliminate" the confiscation of crime victims' property. A spokesperson for the department said it would hold the "evidentiary property" until the conclusion of a criminal case, and added that the department had already returned some seized items.
[33] Police also threw out substantial amounts of trash from the site of the shooting, which was criticized by forensic experts who claimed that the trash collection would result in the destruction of
DNA evidence that could lead to arrests.
[34] The police's after-action report justified the removal of trash from the site, saying that the debris was hindering evidence collection.
[35]
According to the
Baltimore Banner, a 45-foot
elm tree blocked the view of the only static camera overlooking the mass shooting site, which likely blocked police from key footage that could have been used to identify shooting suspects. The tree blocking the camera was removed the day after the shooting.
[36]
Accused
According to police, at least ten different shooters could have been involved in the Brooklyn Day shooting.
[37] As of September 2023, police have made five arrests in connection with the shooting, including four alleged shooters.
[38]
On August 17, 2023, the Baltimore Police Department arrested
18-year-old Tristan Brian Jackson (born April 19, 2005)
[39] of Baltimore on attempted murder charges in connection with the Brooklyn Homes shooting.
[40]
On August 31, police arrested
18-year-old Aaron Brown on numerous assault, gun, and attempted murder charges, and a minor, in connection to the shooting.
[41]
On September 13, police arrested
a 15-year-old boy on 44 charges, including attempted first-degree murder and second-degree murder, in connection to the shooting. According to investigators, he allegedly fired a weapon at several people during the Brooklyn Day party.
[42]
Responses
Maryland Governor Wes Moore and other Baltimore leaders visit the Brooklyn Community Center, 2023
In the morning following the shooting, Maryland Governor
Wes Moore and several other Baltimore leaders released statements expressing their condolences.
[4][43][44] Baltimore Mayor
Brandon Scott also called for further crackdowns on illegal guns coming in from other states[45][46] and criticized people who uploaded videos of the incident to social media for not intervening.
[47] United States President Joe Biden also expressed condolences and called for gun control.[48] Republican Party leaders of the
Maryland General Assembly called for Moore to convene a special session to pass legislation to address gun violence,
[49] which Moore said was not needed.
[50] Moore met with Brooklyn community leaders and people injured by the shooting on July 4, and later spoke at the
Cherry Hill Festival to support gun violence prevention efforts in the city.
[51]
The Baltimore
Fraternal Order of Police released a statement on Twitter calling on Scott to implement a "retention and recruitment plan" for hiring more police in the city, pointing out that there were only seven officers patrolling the area at the time of the shooting.
[23] Officials stated before the shooting that the department had 338 patrol vacancies and had funding to hire an additional 918 patrol positions.
[14] Worley also disputed the staffing claims made by the police union, saying that there were more than seven police in the Southern District at the time.
[52] Baltimore City Councilor Phylicia Porter, whose district includes Brooklyn, called the lack of police an "immense systemic failure"
[4][53] and said that the multiple city agencies, including the police and Housing Authority, should have known to deploy more police ahead of the event.
[54] Scott defended the role of the police as well as the city's Safe Streets gun violence program, saying the focus should "instead be on a few people who cowardly decided to shoot up a big block party celebration for a community".
[55] Worley blamed the lack of police for the event being "unpermitted"
[56] and later said that decisions on whether to send more officers to the neighborhood for the festival happened "too late". He also added that departmental staffing was not an issue for its response, or lack thereof.
[14]
The Baltimore City Council held a hearing on the response from multiple agencies—including the Baltimore Police Department, Housing Authority, Department of Transportation, and MONSE—to the shooting on July 13.
[14] At the hearing, Worley and other leaders of the Baltimore Police Department acknowledged department-wide failures, including a "catastrophic breakdown" in judgement and communications,
[57][58] and admitted responsibility for the lack of police presence at the party. He also said that there was an ongoing investigation into where police were patrolling that night, which included a review of
police body camera footage, dispatch recordings, and GPS locations.
[17] Baltimore Police patrol chief Kevin Jones, in response to criticism about the police's relationship with the community, said that investigators had received 30 tips with information about the mass shooting.
[59] Janet Abrahams, the CEO of the city Housing Authority, said that staff did not see flyers for the party that were circulating in the neighborhood and that officials would be expanding its contracted security force to additional properties, including Brooklyn Homes.
[17] Abrahams also said that officials were exploring evictions for tenants who organized the party without notifying the Housing Authority in advance, which violated the terms of their residency agreements. MONSE interim executive director Stefanie Mavronis defended the city's
youth curfew and the role of Safe Streets and its workers leading up to the shooting, pointing to the successes made through the agency's de-escalation strategy in parts of Baltimore, but said that she had not yet reviewed workers' logs about their efforts in the Brooklyn Homes area the night of the shooting.
[57] A few days after the hearing, the Housing Authority said it would revise its policies toward event authorization, including requiring residents to get written approval from the agency to use any indoor or outdoor common areas in events.
[60][61]
On August 30, 2023, the Baltimore Police Department released its 173-page "after-action report" , which faulted police supervisors for taking a "hands-off approach" to intervening in the Brooklyn Day celebration, even as 9-1-1 calls increased, and police officers for showing "little to no concern for public safety" and gathering no meaningful intelligence ahead of the party.
[62][63] The report also recommended a series of leadership changes within the Baltimore Police Department.
[64] Following the report, some command-level supervisors were reassigned and disciplinary actions were taken against others.
[65]
.jpg)
