HOCKEY: BLACK Matt Petgrave manslaughter charges: Could Steelers player receive jail-time for WM Adam Johnson's death?

Arheel's Uncle

Senior Reporter

Matt Petgrave manslaughter charges: Could Steelers player receive jail-time for Adam Johnson's death?​


By Ankit Kumar
Modified Oct 31, 2023 13:12 GMT

follow icon Follow Us

Matt Petgrave Manslaughter Charges: Could Steelers player receive jail-time for Adam Johnson
Matt Petgrave manslaughter charges: Could Steelers player receive jail-time for Adam Johnson's death?


The recent tragic incident that resulted in the death of Adam Johnson has ignited debate over whether the other player involved, Matt Petgrave, should face criminal charges for his role in the event.
The incident took place during a game in England when Johnson, a former NHL forward for the Pittsburgh Penguins, suffered a fatal injury. Johnson's neck was slashed by Matt Petgrave's skate blade in a freak accident.
The unfortunate incident unfolded during a game between the Nottingham Panthers and the Sheffield Steelers, with approximately 8,000 spectators in attendance.
In the 35th minute of the game, Johnson fell to the ice following a collision with Petgrave. Despite receiving immediate medical attention, Johnson tragically lost his life as a result of the severe injury.
Also read: Adam Johnson’s fiancée Ryan Wolfe
The incident has sparked discussions surrounding potential legal repercussions, specifically whether Petgrave could face manslaughter charges. Legal experts have weighed in on the matter, expressing doubts about the likelihood of such charges being brought against him.
In a discussion with Newsweek, Professor Nicola Lacey, specializing in law, gender and social policy at the London School of Economics and Political Science (LSE), said:
"From what I have read on the news, it seems very unlikely the CPS [Crown Prosecution Service] would prosecute: for manslaughter you need either gross negligence — a really large departure from normal standards of care such as to justify criminal liability; or an unlawful and dangerous act — the latter only likely if for example there had been a pretty flagrant breach of the sport's rules."
She added:
"If it was really a 'freak accident,' neither of those tests would be met; and the CPS can only prosecute where there is a realistic chance of conviction."
Jeremy Horder, another expert from LSE, explained that injuries arising from ordinary lawful sporting contests generally fall within the realm of "ordinary contact" and do not typically result in legal liability.
"Essentially, the position is that injuries caused in the course of an ordinary lawful sporting contest are within the bounds of 'ordinary contact' and hence do not give rise to liability, even when, for example, they contravene a rule of the game by amounting to a foul or violent conduct," Horder said.
"However, very extreme recklessness, for example wearing deliberately extra sharpened boots, or something, or a deliberately inflicted injury of a serious kind might fall outside this exception, and fall to be dealt with like any other assault leading to a death. I am not aware that anything of this nature was involved in this case."

South Yorkshire Police is investigating Adam Johnson and Matt Petgrave's collision​

While South Yorkshire Police continues its investigation, it has urged the public to avoid speculating about the circumstances surrounding the incident.
South Yorkshire Police's statement reads:
"Our officers remain at the scene carrying out inquiries, and our investigation into the circumstances surrounding the incident remains ongoing.
"We would encourage the public to avoid speculation regarding the incident while we continue our inquiries."
Also read BLACK BULL$HIT: Matt Petgrave "left distraught" following Adam Johnson's death, receives offensive messages from trolls:
 
Karate kick, Kung Fu kick


"It was a Kung fu kick": Matt Petgrave's involvement deemed intentional by ex-Flyers defenceman Chris Therien​

By Arnab Mondal
Modified Oct 31, 2023 20:45 GMT

 
Last edited:


Manslaughter arrest in death of hockey player whose neck was cut with skate blade​

The Pittsburgh Penguins and Anaheim Ducks gather at center ice, before an NHL hockey game in...


The Pittsburgh Penguins and Anaheim Ducks gather at center ice, before an NHL hockey game in Pittsburgh, Monday, Oct. 30, 2023, to honor former Penguin player Adam Johnson, shown on scoreboard, who died in while playing in an English hockey league game. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)(AP)

By The Associated Press and BRIAN MELLEY
Published: Nov. 14, 2023 at 10:06 AM MST|Updated: 15 hours ago

LONDON (AP) — Police in England arrested a man Tuesday on suspicion of manslaughter in the death of American ice hockey player Adam Johnson, whose neck was cut by a skate during a game.

Johnson, 29, was playing for the Nottingham Panthers against the Sheffield Steelers on Oct. 28 when he was struck by an opponent’s skate blade in the Elite Ice Hockey League game at Sheffield’s home arena.
South Yorkshire Police did not name the suspect or provide his age. He was in police custody.

Matt Petgrave, 31, who plays for Sheffield, was the other player involved in the grisly incident that reverberated around the hockey community and led to moments of silence in the NHL.

Video of the incident shows Johnson skating with the puck toward the Steelers net. Petgrave skates toward
Johnson and collides with another Panthers player. Petgrave’s left skate kicks up as he begins to fall and the blade hits Johnson in the neck.

Both players land on the ice. Petgrave immediately got to his feet. Johnson rose more slowly and as he is helped off the ice, his jersey is covered in blood. He later died at a local hospital.

“Our investigation launched immediately following this tragedy and we have been carrying out extensive inquiries ever since to piece together the events which led to the loss of Adam in these unprecedented circumstances,” Detective Chief Superintendent Becs Horsfall said.

It would be rare, but not unprecedented, for a hockey player to be charged.

Giacinto “Jim” Boni was charged in Italy with culpable homicide after he slashed Miran Schrott in the chest during a game on Jan. 14, 1992, and Schrott died as a result of a cardiac event. Boni pleaded guilty to manslaughter.

Two NHL players in recent history have been charged with a crime in Canada for an on-ice action: Marty McSorley and Todd Bertuzzi.
In 2000, McSorley was found guilty of assault with a deadly weapon for a two-handed slash to the head of Donald Brashear with his stick. He was sentenced to 18 months probation.
In 2004, Bertuzzi pleaded guilty to assault for grabbing Steve Moore from behind and sucker punching him. Bertuzzi agreed to a plea deal and was sentenced to one year probation and 80 hours of community service.

The Panthers said in a statement on social media that Johnson died tragically following a “freak accident.”
Nottingham teammate Westin Michaud, who posted tributes to Johnson, also defended Petgrave for what he said was an “unintentional clip” with the other player that uprighted him.

“The hate that Matt is receiving is terrible and completely uncalled for,” Michaud posted. “It’s clear to me his actions were unintentional and anyone suggesting otherwise is mistaken. Let’s come together and not spread unwarranted hate to someone who needs our support.”

On Sunday, at the Steelers first home game since Johnson’s death, a moment of silence was held for him. Petgrave didn’t play in the game, but fans gave him a standing ovation when his team photo appeared on the scoreboard.

Johnson was a Minnesota native who appeared in a total of 13 NHL games with the Pittsburgh Penguins in the 2018-19 and 2019-20 seasons.

The English Ice Hockey Association, which governs the sport below the Elite League, reacted to Johnson’s death by requiring all players in England to wear neck guards from the start of 2024.

A spokesman for the EIHL said the league cannot comment on an ongoing police investigation. A Nottingham Panthers spokesman said the organization had no comment. Messages seeking comment sent to Johnson’s agent, a friend of the family, and the Sheffield Steelers were not immediately returned.

NHL VP of hockey operations Rod Pasma addressed general managers at their annual November meeting in Toronto on the matter of cut-proof equipment. Pasma said players have far more options than a decade ago, including 10 or more choices for wrist, body and Achilles tendon/foot protection.

“In the neck, we’re getting there,” Pasma said. “We (did not have) many a month ago, but as it sits today, I think there’s up to eight companies on my desk waiting to be cleared, and of those eight there’s probably 12-14 options to wear, should they choose.”

The league’s chief medical officer, Dr. Willem Meeuwisse, said team doctors and trainers took part in a big education session on major lacerations in the spring.
“We’re always tweaking and reviewing that kind of policy and procedure, equipment, personnel so we’re as prepared as possible to deal with a catastrophic injury,” Meeuwisse said. “We’re looking at, always, what could happen and how to prepare to deal with it best, and hopefully we don’t have the kind of bad outcome that happened a few weeks ago.”
 

SNIPPED
Involuntary manslaughter is the main criminal charge at play. It involves unintentionally causing the death of another person as a result of recklessness, negligence or an unlawful act. In these types of cases, the defendant did not intend to kill the person but failed to act with due care, resulting in the unintended death.
This is in contrast to voluntary manslaughter, where the defendant intentionally kills another person without the prior intent to kill. So that charge may apply when someone is killed in the heat of passion or during a fight.

Here, though, involuntary manslaughter is the focus. Did Petgrave intend to raise his leg and in doing so was he reckless or negligent?
While it’s perhaps unlikely that Petgrave will be charged criminally, an involuntary manslaughter charge is not out of the question. In attempting to impede Johnson’s progress, Petgrave plants his right leg to gain the necessary leverage to extend his left leg. As he alters his momentum, the right leg is straightened to support the raising of his left leg with a view to impeding Johnson’s progress. The act has been likened to a karate kick and for good reason.
 

snipped
Aittola, who coached Petgrave during the 2021–2022 season in the Slovak League, made a damning admission about the defenseman's playing style. Speaking to the Finnish newspaper Ilta Sanomat, Aittola expressed a negative view of Petgrave, stating:
"I coached Matt for a very short stint. I wanted to get rid of him immediately ... He has no respect for himself or his opponents. He used to get into a bit of a mess. He is a very dirty player."
Aittola went on to elaborate on his experience with Petgrave, highlighting concerns about the defenseman's lack of respect for opponents, involvement in questionable situations leading to injuries, and a generally dirty playing style.
"I don't think his (Petgrave's) intention was to kill anyone. I don't think he intended to harm anyone ... But if there's one player I'm willing to believe could use his skates to stop an opponent, I think Matt Petgrave could do it. He is an extremely reckless player."
 
Back
Top